If tobirama wasn't an edo, would he have been able to land this attack?

Madara mentions right after this having the advantage due to tobirama and hashirama not being revived at full power, if it was alive tobirama would this attack have at least landed?

Madara mentions right after this having the advantage due to tobirama and hashirama not being revived at full power, if it was alive tobirama would this attack have at least landed?